Home Minister’s panacea of 5 Cs

By K.N Pandita

Home Minister Rajnath Singh has just concluded his 4-day visit to J&K. He spent maximum of his time in Srinagar, and the customary eye wash of visit to Jammu by way of a balancing act.

I looked up in dictionary to find out if HM’s 5-Cs carries some deeper or mysterious meaning. I found none. What does he want to convey and to whom, is my question.

One commonly observed ritual about Kashmir issue is “talk in hyperbole”. Responsible Central and State Ministers all take recourse to hyperbole when they are under pressure to articulate on the genesis of Kashmir question. It is never a straightforward and honest articulation and the reason is that they have to suppress the truth and speak the lie if they want to successfully mislead the people of Kashmir and the nation in general.

The foundation of a huge superstructure of lies and falsehoods about Kashmir rests on what may be axiomatically called ‘wilful suspension of disbelief.’ The first and most enduring foundation stone of this superstructure of falsehood was laid by none other than Sheikh Muhammad Abdullah who sold the double-pronged canard to Nehru, namely (a) Kashmir is the bastion of communal harmony, and (b) Kashmiris reject Jinnah’s two-nation theory and are staunch pro-Indian accessionist. He knew his lies had a big buyer. The second architect of the edifice of Kashmir canard was Nehru who (a) knew the Sheikh was a Goebbelian liar and yet would gave the devil his due, and (b) project Sheikh as a Muslim stalwart leader on Asian horizon to thwart imperial manoeuvres in Asian Continent. Nevertheless, while the Sheikh’s induction of falsehood had a clear goal — achievable or non-achievable is a different story – Nehru misled himself and his nation with spurious idealism. A friend of mine called him “half-baked socialist.”

Amusingly, Kashmiri leadership, irrespective of the fact whether in or out of power, has become pitiable prisoner of hyperbole because (a) it apprehends it will be denuded of political power at any time, and (b) it does not trust its political and ideological constituency. Therefore, telling a lie .is taken as safety valve. Let me be somewhat specific.

The slogan of “aazadi” is the biggest lie Kashmiris have spoken since 1939, the year National Conference was born from the debris of Muslim Conference. This lie became their article of faith in 1990 and has endured till date, two and a half decades. Replace “aazadi” with “Pakistan” and you own the truth. Again, another lie they speak is that they want Pakistan. The truth is that their pro-Pakistan slogan has takers in New Delhi and Islamabad and both throw open state coffers on them, at the same time taking their pound of flesh.

Indians know what Kashmiris want. Feigning innocence, they come with bouquets of various hues like Kashmir ka faisla Kashmir ke log karenge, or Kashmir Hindstan ka taj hai, or Insaniyat ke nate or Kashmir is a unique problem asking for unique solution or more recently 5-Cs. I don’t need to elucidate the fallacious construct of all these outpourings. The taste of pudding is in eating.

For last three years Kashmir unrest almost remained unnoticed by the Central leadership. It believed in (a) let them go on strikes and vandalising as it matters little (b) press for utilization certificates of enormous funds given for various developmental project and (c) let the hawala jinni out of the bottle.

5-Cs tantrum is one of the lies in line with other lies. The fact is Pakistan has convinced the Americans that Kashmir is linked to Afghan crisis and any solution of Afghan crisis must accommodate Kashmir resolution. Actually, former President Obama had encouraged the Track II diplomacy on Kashmir and the process was well afloat. However, events like Pathankot and Uri and the rising crescendo of Pakistani terrorist organizations accelerating their Kashmir jihad put a halt to Track II process.

With Trump administration focusing on Afghan situation and encouraging talks between the two governments, Kashmir issue finds resurgence with American policy planners. Designating LeT and JeM by the State Department, Trump issuing weighty warnings to Pakistan to contain the radical chapters have their indirect fallout and India is supposed to respond to these nuances with subtle reference to Kashmir dispute. Therefore, Home Minister’s 5-Cs and other offers like no scrapping of either 35A or 370 are signals meant more for the US State Department consumption than for the government or the people of Jammu and Kashmir.

Coming together of three main separatist leaders to discuss current situation and the visit of the Home Minister and his holding to them the olive branch all have to be understood in this broad spectrum of regional scenario.

What will be the fate of renewed Track II talks cannot be predicted. Perhaps a clue could be looked for in the outcome of recently held talks between the leadership of Afghanistan and Pakistan.

This notwithstanding, a more significant development has taken place recently with bearing on all that is brewing on the sub-continent. Aspersions cast on Pakistan in the recent BRICS meet, and President XI’s direct mention of some Pakistan-based terrorist organizations, are not too subtle a message to Pakistan that she has to refrain from jeopardizing the interests of world community in peace and stability in Afghanistan. Furthermore, we have to remember that China made no bones in rejecting western perspective of Rohingya issue. China has the fullest information on terrorist training camps established by Pakistan-based terrorist organizations like LeT in Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq and Libya. Beijing knows about the funding sources of Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) and its links with Al-Qaeda, ISI and LeT. Beijing understands that legitimizing terrorist ARSA would only lead to creation of more space for the terrorist groups like those of Haqqani and consequent repercussions on regional strategies. China has made huge investment in Afghanistan and she is not going to play the second fiddle in that country. Therefore, we can safely infer that interests the US and China converge finally on some third party playing a role in regional strategies.

Feelers for surrender by freshers

By K.N. Pandita

Like all regressive activities, militancy, too, has to come to its logical conclusion which is its total effacement. This thinking developed soon among Kashmirian civil society after the separatists refused to interact with the All Party Parliamentary delegation that visited the valley last August. Continue Reading…

India-Pakistan dialogue on Kashmir

By K.N. Pandita

J&K Chief Minister repeats the tantrum of dialogue with Pakistan knowing well there are no takers in India and much less in Pakistan. Not only her late father but even father-son NC chief minister-duo before him had also harped on the same tune. They don’t do it out of gaffe. Continue Reading…

The Exodus of Kashmiri Pandits – excerpt

published on European Foundation for South-Asian Studies EFSAS, July 2017:

… Conclusion: Continue Reading…

Kashmiris mourn killing of another Pak terrorist

By K.N. Pandita

Thousands of Kashmiri youth in various parts of the valley recently mourned the killing of two A++ grade terrorists, one of them a Pakistani national and the other his local accomplice. Continue Reading…

Letter to the Editor

Daily Excelsior, August 2, 2017 – Nawaz Sharief’s ouster


This has reference to the piece titled Coup Instigator by Shri B.L. Saraf (DE 2 Aug). The writer, himself a legal luminary, has rightly touched on the subject of the credibility of Pakistan judiciary particularly the Supreme Court. History of Pakistani judiciary shows us that at many times judges of the Supreme Court have behaved in a partisan manner. Continue Reading…

Amendment Bill and frustrated opposition

By K.N. Pandita

Rajya Sabha has passed the Amendment to the Statistics Data Bill for Jammu and Kashmir, which was earlier passed by the Lok Sabha in April this year. Despite the criticism and reservations of the opposition parties particularly the Congress and CPI the bill was passed. Continue Reading…

Listing Pakistan a terrorist haven

By K.N. Pandita

Should Washington enlisting Pakistan among countries that provide safe haven to terrorists give us any solace? No country will have laughed more heartily than Pakistan on being told so.

Trump is not the first President to play the antics. His two predecessors were no less skilled in the art of playing political hoax. Continue Reading…

Massacre of Swami Amarnath Cave pilgrims

By Kashinath Pandit

Pilgrims anywhere in the world are the messengers of peace. They undertake pilgrimages to seek inner peace for themselves and for the world at large. Shame on Theo-fascists, shame on followers of a false faith and shame on mercenaries who undertake killing of innocent seekers of God’s goodwill to satisfy the inhuman instincts. Do not think that the age of barbarians and cannibals is over. We have them around and we have also around those who worship and adore cannibalism. The fight between virtue and vice or good and evil is the history of mankind and we in this country are in the thick of that battle. Continue Reading…

Letter to the Editor


This is with reference to Editorial ‘A Black Day in Kashmir” (DE 13 July). I must congratulate the writer for giving the true story about the history of 13 July now observed as Martyrs’ Day by J&K Government. It was a black day indeed. Continue Reading…